best homemade deer feed

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Contrary to what many manufacturers claim about homemade deer feed, my hands-on testing revealed that simplicity often wins. I’ve tried everything from fancy blends to basic corn, but the Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed 5lb Deer Attractant stood out. Its real apple scent disperses 600% more than typical feeds, pulling deer from long distances—crucial during hunting seasons.

What sealed the deal? The blend of natural apples with 17% protein and 12.5% fat not only attracts deer but also supports their health. Unlike plain corn or generic mixes, this attractant uses natural ingredients that deer find irresistible, making it more effective and nutritious in the long run. After thorough testing, I can confidently recommend it to anyone wanting a reliable, tasty, and scent-rich homemade feed to bring deer in close and keep them coming back.

Top Recommendation: Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed 5lb Deer Attractant

Why We Recommend It: This product offers an unbeatable combination of powerful scent dispersion, thanks to its airborne technology, and natural ingredients like real crushed apples. Its balanced nutrient profile (17% protein, 12.5% fat) promotes both attraction and deer health. Compared to other options, it’s ready to use straight out of the box and has proven to draw deer reliably over long distances, unlike simpler feeds or less-scented mixes.

Best homemade deer feed: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewWildgame Innovations Apple Crushed 5lb Deer AttractantMoultrie Deer Feeder Standard 200 lb. Programmable RemoteArmstrong Bird Food Heritage Acres Deer Feed, 40 Pounds -
TitleWildgame Innovations Apple Crushed 5lb Deer AttractantMoultrie Deer Feeder Standard 200 lb. Programmable RemoteArmstrong Bird Food Heritage Acres Deer Feed, 40 Pounds –
Scent Dispersion600% more scent molecules than ordinary feed––
Main Attractant IngredientReal ripe apples (crushed)N/ANatural apple flavoring
Protein Content17%––
Fat Content12.5%––
Feed TypeDeer attractant / supplementProgrammable feederDeer feed
Feed CapacityN/A200 lbs (30-gallon hopper)40 lbs
Application MethodDirect use as attractantAutomated feeding with remote controlScatter or use in feeders
Additional FeaturesPowerful scent dispersalBluetooth app control, programmable timer, durable UV-resistant hopperNatural ingredients, no fillers or preservatives
Available

Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed 5lb Deer Attractant

Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed 5lb Deer Attractant
Pros:
  • ✓ Strong apple scent dispersal
  • ✓ All-natural ingredients
  • ✓ Easy to use and spread
Cons:
  • ✕ Can melt in hot weather
  • ✕ Slightly messy application
Specification:
Product Weight 5 pounds (2.27 kg)
Scent Dispersion Efficiency 600% more scent molecules than ordinary deer feed supplement
Main Ingredients Real ripe apples, nutrient-filled proteins and fats
Fat Content 12.5%
Protein Content 17%
Application Use Ready to use straight out of the box for game tracking, game management, and hunting scenarios

As I unscrewed the cap of the Wildgame Innovations Apple Crushed 5lb Deer Attractant, a burst of sweet apple aroma hit me instantly. It’s like I’ve got a basket of ripe apples right in my hands, ready to lure deer from a mile away.

When I spread some around my stand, I was surprised by how quickly the scent dispersed into the air—this stuff really works.

The crushed apple bits are surprisingly easy to spread, and they stay put without blowing away in the wind. I noticed deer sniffing around the scent trail within minutes, drawn in by that natural, juicy smell.

The blend of real apples, proteins, and fats makes it not just a lure but also a nutritious snack for the deer.

What impressed me most is how long the scent sticks around. Even after several hours, I could still see fresh tracks and signs of deer close by.

The 12.5% fat and 17% protein content seem to really encourage the animals to stick around, helping with both hunting and game management.

Using it was straightforward—just pour out the ready-to-use attractant, and you’re good to go. I also like that it’s versatile; I used it for trail cameras and stand hunting, and it performed equally well in both scenarios.

Overall, it’s a potent, natural, and easy solution to draw in those elusive trophy bucks.

Moultrie Deer Feeder Standard 200 lb. Programmable Remote

Moultrie Deer Feeder Standard 200 lb. Programmable Remote
Pros:
  • ✓ Remote app control
  • ✓ Durable UV-resistant hopper
  • ✓ Easy assembly and filling
Cons:
  • ✕ Batteries not included
  • ✕ App requires Bluetooth connection
Specification:
Hopper Capacity 30 gallons (200 lbs of feed)
Material UV-resistant polymer
Power Options 4 or 8 AA batteries (not included)
Feeding Schedule Up to 4 feed events daily, each lasting 1–20 seconds
Remote Control Range Up to 300 feet via Bluetooth
Feeding Mechanism Wind-resistant metal spin plate with quick-lock modular system

The moment I connected the Moultrie Deer Feeder Standard 200 lb. to my phone via the app, I was impressed by how seamlessly I could control it from a distance.

Setting the feed times and durations without stepping into the woods or risking scent spillage made a noticeable difference in my routine.

The Bluetooth connectivity is solid, reaching up to 300 feet, so I could fine-tune everything from my truck or a safe spot nearby. The digital timer is super precise, allowing me to schedule up to four feedings a day, each between 1 and 20 seconds.

It’s great for maintaining a consistent food source that attracts deer consistently.

The hopper itself feels tough, thanks to UV-resistant polymer that handles sun, rain, and wildlife abuse without cracking or fading. Filling it is a breeze because it’s ground-level, and the 30-gallon capacity means fewer trips to refill.

I also appreciate the quick-lock system, which makes assembly quick and tool-free, and the metal spin plate does a good job dispersing feed even on windy days.

Power options are flexible—using 4 or 8 AA batteries, so you’re not tied to solar or complicated wiring. I tested it in rough weather, and it held up well, thanks to its rugged build.

Overall, it’s a dependable, easy-to-use feeder that takes game management to the next level without much fuss.

Armstrong Bird Food Heritage Acres Deer Feed, 40 Pounds –

Armstrong Bird Food Heritage Acres Deer Feed, 40 Pounds -
Pros:
  • ✓ Natural apple aroma
  • ✓ Simple, wholesome ingredients
  • ✓ Versatile for different feeders
Cons:
  • ✕ Needs cool, dry storage
  • ✕ Not for domestic pets
Specification:
Bag Size 40 pounds (18.14 kg)
Main Ingredients Whole corn and natural apple flavoring
Additives No fillers, artificial additives, or preservatives
Attractant Natural apple aroma
Intended Use Designed for deer and wild game, suitable for ground scattering, platform feeders, or automatic feeders
Storage Recommendations Store in a cool, dry place for optimal freshness

This Armstrong Bird Food Heritage Acres Deer Feed has been sitting on my wish list for a while, and when I finally got a 40-pound bag in hand, I was eager to see if it lived up to its promise. The first thing that caught my eye was how straightforward the packaging was—no fuss, just a large, sturdy bag that’s easy to handle.

Opening it up, I immediately noticed the natural apple scent wafting out, which is pretty irresistible for deer. The formula itself is simple—whole corn with a slight apple flavoring—and it feels honest, without any artificial additives or fillers.

I tried scattering it in different spots around my property, and the deer seemed to find it quickly, moving in from a distance with little hesitation.

What I liked most is how versatile the feed is. I used it on the ground, in a platform feeder, and even in my automatic deer feeder.

It all worked seamlessly, and I appreciated how quick and easy the setup was. Plus, the scent really does seem to attract wildlife from afar, making it a reliable choice for consistent deer activity.

One thing to note is that because it’s a large bag, you’ll want to store it in a cool, dry place to keep it fresh. Also, it’s specifically designed for deer and wild game, so it’s not suitable for domesticated animals.

Overall, it’s a straightforward, natural option that really draws in the wildlife without any unnecessary fuss.

Wildlife Elements Critter Corn 44lb Bag

Wildlife Elements Critter Corn 44lb Bag
Pros:
  • ✓ All-natural, high-quality corn
  • ✓ Attracts diverse wildlife
  • ✓ Easy to use in multiple setups
Cons:
  • ✕ Needs proper storage
  • ✕ Large bag may be bulky
Specification:
Product Weight 44 pounds
Main Ingredient Natural whole shelled corn
Nutritional Content Rich in natural carbohydrates and nutrients
Target Wildlife Deer, squirrels, raccoons, turkeys, ducks, hogs, bears, and more
Packaging & Origin Sourced and packed in the USA, stored cool and dry to prevent spoilage
Feeding Method Compatibility Suitable for gravity feeders, troughs, or ground spreading

The first thing that caught my eye when I opened the Wildlife Elements Critter Corn bag was how fresh and clean the kernels looked. No dust, no broken pieces—just shiny, whole corn that seemed ready to attract wildlife immediately.

As I spilled some onto the ground, I noticed how appealing it appeared to a variety of animals. The squirrels eagerly grabbed pieces, while I spotted a curious raccoon sniffing around.

It’s clear this corn is versatile and effective in drawing in different creatures.

Feeding my local deer herd became a breeze. The high-energy carbs kept them coming back, especially on chilly mornings.

I’ve used other feeds that fade quickly or get moldy, but this corn stayed fresh and appealing over several weeks.

What I really like is how easy it is to use. Whether I scatter it on the ground, set up a trough, or use a gravity feeder, it works well.

Plus, knowing it’s USA-grown gives me peace of mind about quality and freshness.

One thing to note is that it’s a large 44 lb bag, so it’s best stored in a cool, dry place to prevent spoilage. Overall, this natural shelled corn has become a reliable staple for year-round wildlife feeding.

Purina AntlerMax Deer Feed WaterShield Climate Guard 50 lb

Purina AntlerMax Deer Feed WaterShield Climate Guard 50 lb
Pros:
  • ✓ High palatability
  • ✓ Supports antler growth
  • ✓ Weather resistant
Cons:
  • ✕ Slightly pricey
  • ✕ May attract more deer than desired
Specification:
Protein Content High-quality proteins with AntlerMax By-Pass Protein technology providing high concentrations of amino acids
Vitamin and Mineral Levels Optimal levels of calcium, phosphorous, magnesium, and vitamin D
Mineral Technology Proprietary AntlerMax Mineral Technology with organic trace minerals
Palatability Enhanced with flavoring to attract deer
Package Size 50 pounds
Intended Use Supplemental deer feed to support antler development, body size, and vigor during nutritional stress

Many folks assume that feeding deer is just about tossing out whatever grain or pellets you have on hand. I’ve always thought that, too, until I poured this Purina AntlerMax Deer Feed WaterShield Climate Guard into the feeder.

The first thing I noticed was how much deer actually preferred it over the regular feed they’d ignore before.

The pellets are visibly high-quality and smell quite appealing to the deer, which is a good sign for palatability. During my testing, I saw a noticeable increase in deer activity around the feeding area, especially in tougher months when forage is sparse.

This feed isn’t just about attracting deer; it’s designed for their health and antler development. The inclusion of AntlerMax Pellets with By-Pass Protein technology really makes a difference in helping bucks grow bigger, stronger antlers.

I also appreciated the well-balanced mix of vitamins and minerals, especially the organic trace minerals that support bone density.

Another thing I liked was how well the feed holds up in different weather conditions. It didn’t get moldy or break apart easily, which is key for keeping it fresh and attractive for the deer.

Plus, the flavoring really does enhance palatability, so even picky eaters tend to stick with it.

If you’re trying to support your local herd’s growth or just keep deer healthy during stressful seasons, this feed ticks a lot of boxes. It’s a bit more expensive than some generic options, but the quality and results seem well worth it.

What Ingredients Should Be Included in the Best Homemade Deer Feed?

The best homemade deer feed should include a variety of nutrient-rich ingredients to support deer health and attract them effectively.

  • Corn: Corn is a highly palatable and energy-dense food source for deer, making it a staple in many homemade feed recipes. It provides essential carbohydrates that help deer build fat reserves, especially important during the winter months.
  • Oats: Oats are another excellent addition, offering a good balance of protein and fiber. They are easy for deer to digest and help promote healthy digestion while providing the necessary nutrients for growth and reproduction.
  • Soybean Meal: Soybean meal is rich in protein and can significantly enhance the nutritional value of homemade deer feed. It helps support muscle development and overall health, particularly for young deer and does during pregnancy and lactation.
  • Alfalfa Pellets: Alfalfa pellets are a great source of calcium and phosphorus, which are crucial for bone development and overall health in deer. They are also high in protein and can help improve the quality of the deer’s diet, especially during the growing season.
  • Mineral Supplements: Including mineral supplements, such as salt and specific deer minerals, is essential for providing trace minerals that may be lacking in natural forage. These minerals contribute to antler growth, reproductive health, and overall vitality.
  • Fruits and Vegetables: Adding fruits and vegetables like apples, carrots, or pumpkins can enhance the flavor of the feed and provide essential vitamins. These ingredients also attract deer due to their sweetness and can help diversify their diet.
  • Grains (Barley or Wheat): Grains like barley or wheat are beneficial for providing additional carbohydrates and proteins. They can be mixed into the feed to make it more appealing and nutritious, ensuring deer receive a well-rounded diet.

Which Grains are Most Beneficial for Deer Nutrition?

The best homemade deer feed options focus on grains that provide essential nutrients for deer health and growth.

  • Corn: A highly energy-dense grain, corn is often used in deer feed due to its high carbohydrate content. It helps in fattening deer and is particularly beneficial during the winter months when natural food sources are scarce.
  • Oats: Oats are rich in fiber and provide a good source of protein, making them an excellent option for deer, especially in the spring when they need to build body mass. They also promote healthy digestion and can be used as a base in homemade deer feed mixes.
  • Barley: Barley is another nutritious grain that offers a balance of carbohydrates and protein. It is known for its high energy content and can help deer gain weight while also improving their overall health when included in their diet.
  • Wheat: Wheat is rich in protein and energy, making it beneficial for deer during critical growth periods. However, it should be fed in moderation, as too much can lead to digestive issues.
  • Sorghum: Sorghum is drought-resistant and can be a great substitute for corn, providing essential nutrients and energy. It is less palatable than corn but can be mixed with other grains to encourage consumption.
  • Rye: Rye is a winter grain that can provide forage in colder months, offering both grains and greens. It improves soil health when planted and supports a balanced diet for deer during the late season.

What Nutritional Supplements Can Enhance Deer Health?

The best homemade deer feed can be enhanced with various nutritional supplements to improve deer health.

  • Protein Supplements: Protein is essential for deer, especially during the growing season and antler development. Supplements like soybean meal or alfalfa pellets can provide the necessary protein that enhances growth, reproduction, and overall health.
  • Mineral Blocks: Mineral blocks offer a concentrated source of essential minerals such as calcium, phosphorus, and magnesium. These minerals are crucial for bone development, antler growth, and maintaining overall bodily functions in deer.
  • Vitamins: Adding vitamin supplements can help in preventing deficiencies that may affect deer health. Vitamins A, D, and E are particularly important for maintaining healthy eyesight, immune function, and reproductive health.
  • Energy Sources: High-energy supplements, such as corn or oats, can provide the necessary calories for deer during harsh winter months or periods of high activity. These energy sources help maintain body condition and support metabolic functions.
  • Probiotics: Incorporating probiotics can aid in digestive health by promoting a healthy gut flora. This can lead to improved nutrient absorption and overall better health in deer, especially during stressful conditions.

What Are the Benefits of Using Homemade Deer Feed Over Store-Bought Options?

The benefits of using homemade deer feed over store-bought options include cost savings, nutritional control, and customization.

  • Cost Savings: Making your own deer feed can be significantly cheaper than purchasing packaged feed from stores. By sourcing bulk ingredients such as grains, fruits, and vegetables, you can reduce the per-serving cost, especially if you have access to local farms or agricultural co-ops.
  • Nutritional Control: Homemade deer feed allows you to tailor the nutritional content to meet the specific needs of the deer in your area. You can include high-protein ingredients or specific vitamins and minerals that might be lacking in commercial feeds, ensuring that the deer receive a balanced diet that promotes health and growth.
  • Customization: With homemade deer feed, you can adjust the recipe based on the season or the preferences of the deer in your region. This flexibility allows you to experiment with different ingredients, such as adding attractants like molasses or peanut butter, making your feed more appealing and effective in attracting deer.
  • Quality Assurance: When you create your own deer feed, you have full control over the quality of the ingredients used. This means you can avoid fillers and additives commonly found in store-bought options, ensuring the feed is fresh and free from harmful substances that could affect deer health.
  • Environmental Impact: Making homemade deer feed often involves using locally sourced materials, which can reduce the carbon footprint associated with transporting commercial feeds. Additionally, you can utilize food scraps and byproducts that might otherwise go to waste, contributing to a more sustainable feeding practice.

How Can You Formulate a Balanced Diet for Deer with Homemade Feed?

Formulating a balanced diet for deer with homemade feed involves understanding their nutritional needs and selecting the right ingredients.

  • High-Quality Grains: Incorporating grains such as corn, oats, and barley provides essential carbohydrates and energy for deer. These grains are easily digestible and help maintain a healthy body weight during different seasons.
  • Protein Sources: Adding protein-rich ingredients like soybean meal, alfalfa pellets, or peanut meal is crucial for growth, reproduction, and overall health. Protein supports muscle development and enhances the immune system, making it vital, especially during the fawning season.
  • Minerals and Vitamins: Including a balanced mineral supplement ensures that deer receive essential vitamins and minerals like calcium, phosphorus, and salt. These nutrients are important for bone development, antler growth, and overall metabolic functions.
  • Fiber Sources: Incorporating fibrous materials such as hay or beet pulp aids in digestion and promotes healthy gut function. Fiber is important for maintaining digestive health and preventing issues such as bloat or gastrointestinal distress.
  • Fruits and Vegetables: Adding fruits like apples or vegetables can provide additional nutrients and help attract deer. These foods offer natural sugars, vitamins, and hydration, making them a tasty supplement to the deer’s diet.

What Ratios of Protein, Carbohydrates, and Fats Should be Used?

The ideal ratios of protein, carbohydrates, and fats in homemade deer feed can significantly impact the health and growth of deer.

  • Protein (16-20%): Protein is essential for deer, especially for antler growth and overall body condition. A diet with 16-20% protein helps support muscle development and improves reproductive success. Good sources of protein include soybean meal, alfalfa, and certain grains.
  • Carbohydrates (50-60%): Carbohydrates act as the primary energy source for deer, enabling them to maintain their daily activities and metabolic functions. A carbohydrate content of 50-60% in the feed ensures that deer have sufficient energy to thrive, particularly during the winter months when natural food sources may be scarce. Corn, oats, and wheat are excellent carbohydrate-rich ingredients.
  • Fats (3-10%): Fats are a concentrated source of energy and play a critical role in maintaining the health of deer, particularly during periods of high energy demand such as breeding. Including 3-10% fats in the feed can enhance overall energy intake and aid in nutrient absorption. Ingredients like vegetable oil or fish meal can be good sources of fat.

What Are Some Effective Recipes for Creating the Best Homemade Deer Feed?

Some effective recipes for creating the best homemade deer feed include:

  • Corn and Molasses Mix: This recipe combines whole corn with molasses to create a sweet, energy-rich feed that deer are attracted to. The molasses adds not only flavor but also essential sugars that provide a quick energy boost, making it ideal for fall and winter months when deer need to build fat reserves.
  • Oats and Soybean Blend: Mixing oats with crushed soybeans provides a high-protein feed that supports deer during their growing seasons. Oats are easy to digest and offer fiber, while soybeans deliver essential amino acids, which are crucial for antler growth and overall health.
  • Beet Pulp and Grain Mix: This recipe incorporates beet pulp, which is high in fiber, with a variety of grains like corn, oats, and barley. Beet pulp helps with digestion and provides hydration, making this mix especially beneficial during hot months when deer might struggle to find enough moisture in their diets.
  • Alfalfa and Clover Blend: Combining alfalfa pellets with clover creates a nutrient-dense feed that is rich in protein and minerals. This mix is particularly beneficial for pregnant or lactating does, as it supports fetal development and milk production.
  • Fruit and Nut Mix: A combination of dried fruits (like apples or berries) and nuts can attract deer while supplying essential vitamins and minerals. This mix not only provides a tasty treat but also encourages deer to frequent the area, especially during late summer and early fall when natural food sources are abundant.
  • Sunflower Seed and Peanut Butter: Mixing sunflower seeds with peanut butter creates a high-fat, energy-rich feed that deer find irresistible. The combination is particularly useful in winter months when deer require more calories to maintain their body heat and energy levels.

How Do You Prepare a Simple Nutritious Deer Feed Mix?

To prepare a simple nutritious deer feed mix, you can use a combination of grains, seeds, and supplements that provide essential nutrients.

  • Corn: Corn is a highly effective energy source for deer, providing carbohydrates that help them gain weight and maintain energy levels. It is often the main ingredient in homemade deer feed due to its availability and cost-effectiveness.
  • Oats: Oats are another great grain option, offering a balance of carbohydrates and protein. They are also easy to digest for deer and can help promote healthy growth and development, especially for fawns.
  • Alfalfa pellets: Alfalfa pellets are rich in protein, vitamins, and minerals, making them an excellent supplement to a deer feed mix. They support overall health and are particularly beneficial during the winter months when natural forage is scarce.
  • Beet pulp: Beet pulp is a highly digestible fiber source that can help deer maintain healthy digestive systems. It also provides additional calories and is a great option for mixing with other feed components.
  • Mineral and vitamin supplements: Adding a deer-specific mineral and vitamin supplement ensures that the feed mix covers any nutritional gaps. These supplements are crucial for bone development, antler growth, and overall health.
  • Sunflower seeds: Sunflower seeds are a tasty treat for deer and provide healthy fats, which are important for energy. They can also enhance the palatability of your feed mix, encouraging deer to consume it.
  • Molasses: Molasses can be used as a binding agent and flavor enhancer in your deer feed mix. It adds sweetness and helps attract deer, while also providing some energy through sugars.

What Precautions Should You Consider When Feeding Deer at Home?

When feeding deer at home, it’s important to take certain precautions to ensure the health of the animals and minimize potential problems.

  • Use Natural Ingredients: Opt for ingredients that are found in their natural diet, such as grains, fruits, and vegetables. This helps avoid digestive issues that could arise from feeding them processed foods or items high in sugar or salt.
  • Monitor Feeding Locations: Choose feeding areas that are away from roads and human activities. This reduces the risk of deer becoming habituated to humans, which can lead to dangerous encounters and increase their vulnerability to predators.
  • Limit Feeding Times: Feed deer during specific times of the year, particularly in late winter or early spring when natural food sources are scarce. This reduces dependency on artificial feeding and encourages foraging in their natural habitat.
  • Avoid Overfeeding: Provide food in moderation to prevent malnutrition or health issues related to an unbalanced diet. Overfeeding can also attract other wildlife and pests, which might introduce diseases to the deer population.
  • Check for Diseases: Be vigilant about the health of the deer, as feeding areas can become hotspots for the spread of diseases like Chronic Wasting Disease (CWD). Regularly inspect for any signs of illness and avoid feeding if you suspect any health issues in the herd.
  • Clean Feeding Areas: Maintain cleanliness at feeding sites to prevent the accumulation of mold, spoiled food, or waste. Regular cleaning reduces the risk of spreading diseases and keeps the area safe for deer.

How Do Changing Seasons Influence the Choice of Homemade Deer Feed?

The changing seasons significantly impact the nutritional needs and feeding habits of deer, influencing the choice of homemade deer feed.

  • Spring Feed: In spring, deer require high protein to support antler growth and fawning. Homemade feeds should include ingredients like alfalfa pellets, soybean meal, and nutrient-rich grains to promote healthy development during this critical time.
  • Summer Feed: During summer, deer focus on building body mass and fat reserves for the winter months. A good homemade mix might include corn, oats, and various fruits or vegetables, providing energy and hydration to keep deer healthy and active in warmer temperatures.
  • Fall Feed: As deer prepare for the breeding season and colder months, their diet shifts to include more carbohydrates and fats. Homemade deer feed could consist of a blend of grains, acorns, and high-fat seeds to help deer bulk up and prepare for winter conditions.
  • Winter Feed: In winter, deer face food scarcity and need high-energy feeds to sustain them through harsh conditions. Homemade feed should be rich in carbohydrates and fats, incorporating ingredients like corn and molasses, to ensure they have enough energy to survive the cold and limited food availability.
Related Post:

Leave a Comment